Pet Society Fishing – Fish and Bait List
[Updated November 6, 2009; 4:08am UTC - Updates are noted in red text. Wow, it's been so long since I've taken my pet fishing! 
Just added a few things I managed to catch today.]
Pet Society has introduced a Fishing mini-game, and I’ve been trying out different bait to see what I can catch with them. I might be making a full-out Pet Society Fishing guide if I have enough time and coins (for buying bait, of course!), but for now here’s a list of what I’ve caught so far and what bait I used.
NOTICE: This is not a complete list of fish that can be caught in the game! I only write down whatever I catch whenever I take my pet fishing, so I really have no way of telling if I’ve caught all the fish that can possibly be caught or not, or if they can be caught with other bait that I haven’t tried out yet. I don’t post fish/bait unless I’ve caught them myself!
Decorative Items
These items obviously aren’t fish (no, the Sea Urchin doesn’t count as one); they’re merely decorative items (your pet cannot interact with them) that can be placed around your pet’s home or inside your Aquarium. All these items can be Recycled for 10 Recycle points each and cannot be sold.
- Sea Urchin – Biscuit/Pumpkin/Pear/Corn/Leek/Broccoli/Hot Dog/Onion/Salami/Pear/Banana/Strawberry/Bread
- Seaweed - Corn/Broccoli/Grapes/Meatball/Cheese/Melon/Coconut Half/Rare Steak/Strawberry/Cheeseburger/Cheese/Pear/Cauliflower/Carrot/Biscuit
- Message in a Bottle – Pear/Lemon/Cauliflower/Grapes/Bread/Pizza Slice/Courgette/Salami/Cheeseburger/Rare Steak/Cheese/Biscuit/Onion/Bread/Strawberry/Classic Toffee Apple
- Soda Can – Pineapple/Coconut Half/Pumpkin/Pizza Slice/Pink Donut/Courgette/Onion/Strawberry/Carrot/Salami/Pear/Corn/Rare Steak/Cheese/Leek/Cheese/Biscuit
- Broken Pot - Meatball/Coconut Half/Biscuit/Watermelon/Melon/Corn/Coconut Half/Carrot/Rare Steak/Lemon/Cheese/Strawberry/Biscuit
- Clam with Pearl – Gummi Eyeball/Soft Pretzel
- Rusted Anchor – Halloween Candy Cane
- Bike Wheel – Pear/Grapes/Cheese/Pineapple/Pumpkin /Pizza Slice/Watermelon/Onion/Corn/Coconut Half/Carrot/Rare Steak/Banana/Rare Steak/Rotten Vegetable/Meatball/Strawberry/Cauliflower
- Coral - Apple/Pear/Biscuit/Corn/Leek/Melon/Biscuit/Rare Steak/Coconut Half/Chocolate Soft Serve/Banana/Cheese
- Empty Bottle – Pear/Lemon/Apple/Cauliflower/Meatball/Cheese/Biscuit/Courgette/Hot Dog/Carrot/Donut/Corn/Rare Steak/Strawberry/Tiny Candy Corn/Soft Pretzel
- Sea Anemone – Strawberry
- Amberstone Bug - Soft Pretzel
- Blue Sea Urchin Shell - Strawberry/Pear/Carrot/Lemon
- Old Boot – Apple/Pear/Cheese/Melon/Biscuit/Rare Steak/Courgette/Hot Dog/Strawberry/Carrot/Coconut Half/Lemon/Meatball/Gummi Ghost
- Sea Star Baby Doll – Broccoli/Bread/Pizza Slice/Strawberry/Melon/Salami/Corn/Carrot/Chocolate Soft Serve/Rare Steak/Banana/Cheese/Cauliflower/Biscuit/Onion
- Conch Shell – Pear/Pineapple/Bread/Pizza Slice/Carrot/Cheeseburger/Baby Milk/Corn/Lemon/Rare Steak/Biscuit/Strawberry/Onion/Leek/Grapes
- Fish Bones – Leek/Apple/Cauliflower/Grapes/Pineapple/Pumpkin/Watermelon/Hot Dog/Pear/Coconut Half/Corn/Rare Steak/Cheese/Lemon/Strawberry/Biscuit/Carrot
Aquatic Creatures
These creatures can be placed inside an Aquarium where they’ll swim around for your pet’s amusement. They can be Recycled for 30 Recycle points or sold for 4 Coins each. You can only have five of each kind of aquatic creature at a time; if you catch more your pet will automatically throw it back after catching it.
- Blowfish – Meatball/Carrot/Strawberry
- Cheesefish - Cheese
- Green Discus - Cheese/Rare Steak/Bread/Carrot/Strawberry
- Squid - Banana/Homegrown Orange/Leek/Donut/Pink Donut/Homegrown Apple/Homegrown Cupcake/Homegrown Carrot/Homegrown Turnip/Homegrown Cabbage/Donut/Homegrown Apple/Homegrown Coconut/Cauliflower
- Orangefish - Homegrown Orange
- Chocolatefish – Chocolate Heart
- Puppyfish- Bone
- Dogfish – Cheese/Donut/Rare Steak/Carrot
- Paddlefish - Pear/Leek/Coconut Half/Pink Donut/Homegrown Apple/Rare Steak/Strawberry/Biscuit/Cheese/Lemon
- Clownfish - Lemon/Cauliflower/Pineapple/Coconut Half/Cheeseburger/Donut/Strawberry/Onion/Cheese/Carrot/Soft Pretzel
- Frontosa - Pear/Apple/Meatball/Melon/Onion/Salami/Donut/Cheeseburger/Pear/Chocolate Soft Serve/Biscuit/Cauliflower/Grapes
- Cupcakefish – Homegrown Cupcake
- Sheepfish - Carrot
- Spotted Bass – Broccoli/Cheese/Strawberry/Bread/Leek/Strawberry
- Flounder - Carrot/Corn/Donut/Strawberry/Cheese
- Watermelon Fish - Melon
- Strawberry Donutfish - Pink Donut
- Sardine - Pear/Watermelon/Pink Donut/Courgette/Homegrown Cabbage/Homegrown Turnip/Donut
- Crab – Donut/Cheese/Rare Steak/Cauliflower
- Carp – Watermelon/Pink Donut/Chocolate Soft Serve/Strawberry/Pear/Bread/Grapes
- Loverootfish - Homegrown Sweetheart Root
- Silver Arowana – Rare Steak/Hot Dog/Donut/Pink Donut/Chocolate Soft Serve/Strawberry
- Red Demekin Goldfish - Homegrown Halloween Lolly
- Golden Butterflyfish - Donut/Broccoli/Strawberry
- Lovefish - Strawberry/Onion
- Applefish - Apple
- Bluegill – Strawberry/Donut/Cheese/Rare Steak/Lemon
- Blue Ram – Donut/Broccoli/Lemon
- Seahorse – Carrot
- Bananafish - Homegrown Banana
- Altum Angelfish – Biscuit/Cauliflower/Meatball/Pear/Banana/Strawberry
- Starfish - Biscuit/Homegrown Cupcake/Homegrown Orange/Banana/Homegrown Cupcake/Banana/Pink Donut/Onion/Melon/Donut/Baby Milk/Homegrown Cabbage/Homegrown Sweetheart Root/Homegrown Apple/Chocolate Heart/Homegrown Turnip/Rare Steak/Strawberry
- Shrimp – Broccoli/Pink Donut/Rare Steak/Grapes
- Golden White Cloud – Homegrown Halloween Lolly
- Schooling Bannerfish – Donut/Rare Steak/Strawberry/Grapes/Soft Pretzel
- Octopus – Homegrown Sweetheart Root/Homegrown Cabbage/Homegrown Carrot/Homegrown Turnip/Rare Steak/Homegrown Apple/Homegrown Cupcake/Strawberry/Carrot/Halloween Candy
Click here, here, and here to view images of the listed items.
More fish/items will be added whenever I take my pet fishing, so feel free to keep coming back for updates! And thank you to the helpful players below who mention other possible bait/fish in their comments below! I’ll try your suggestions out and add them if I get the same results, but your comments will be retained so that other players can try them out for themselves! Keep your comments coming so we can help each other catch all those darn fish! 
hi i caught a sheep fish…is there another sets of fish????? if you dont belive you can visit my facebook account, same email add…thanks
As implied by the first few lines in this post (“There are new fish available in the pond now! I’ll try to catch them ASAP”), I haven’t caught all the fish in the pond yet. I wouldn’t be surprised if there were lots of other fish that I haven’t caught yet.
how do youc catach a sheep fish can you give me a list of all the fish tyou have cout and what bait i nned
Um…Ryan, were you referring to me or Emdyey? As I’ve mentioned there are still fish that I haven’t caught, so this is the complete list of what I have so far.
Hi! I caught Sheepfish with Biscuit ^^ You guys can try it!!!
i caught a sheepfish using the pink donut (while trying to catch the strawberry donut fish)
can sumone please tell me how to catch a red salmon and a catfish
i have many fish in my pets chest and he does not throw them back in if he catches more
@Gemma:What I said was “You can only have five of each kind of aquatic creature at a time”, meaning that if, for example, I already own five Clownfish, my fish will throw back any other Clownfish I catch. My pet has a lot of fish in her chest too, but throws back any type of fish that I already have five pieces of.
Not sure if there’s a similar limit for the decorative items like Broken Pots and stuff though.
I caught a sheep fish by 20 carrots
blue ram is half coconut
You can catch a Sheepfish with:
Strawberry
Carrot
Biscuit
As far as I know.
I’ve caught majority of mine with Strawberries.
Like the Lovefish, Dog Fish, 2 Sheepfish, and most on that list.
Things I caught with a Carrot:
Blue Sea Urchin Shell
Sheepfish
Blue Ram
Shrimp
Octopus
Altum Angelfish
Golden Butterflyfish
Lovefish
Crab
Pufferfish
Blowfish
i caught dog fish with bone. MAkes sense, i caught shrimp with half coconut weird, shrimp cannot eat that much, shouldn’t i get back a quarter of coconut?
I got a red salmon using carrot bought from the food store.
I caught ‘Clam with Pearl’ with strawberry.
i caught a lemonfish with 25 lemons
i just caught a sea anemone with a carrot is one of the new fish?
you can catch a golden butterfly fish with a biscut
caught a red salmon with a strawberry donut:)
sea slug!!! with a half a coconut
Hey! I caught a sheepfish with an onion! You can check my profile if you don’t believe me! I published it!
- b x
Haha. I caught the red samon with a pink donut TRYING to catch the donut fish XD
what bait i can catch shark?
i caught a macaroon fish with a waffle and milk
As much as I appreciate all your comments, please do not post “Add me” requests here! I’ll consider those as spam and delete them. If your post contains some tips regarding fishing AND an “add me” request, I’ll edit your comment to remove the “add me” portion of it.
Sorry for this, but aside from “add me” requests not being relevant to this post, posting your e-mail addresses as text in your comments like that might cause you to get spammed by the spammers who trawl blogs for e-mail addresses.
milyah caught a magnificent Macaronfish with Very Small Homegrown Carrot in Pet Society!
milyah caught a magnificent Puppyfish with Bone in Pet Society!
milyah caught a magnificent Crab with Biscuit in Pet Society!
milyah caught a magnificent Sheepfish with Carrot in Pet Society!
milyah caught a magnificent Red Demekin Goldfish with Carrot in Pet Society!
milyah caught a magnificent Frontosa with Carrot in Pet Society!
i think carrot can help to get many nice fishes ~
by the way how do you catch a dog fish
and im just wondering cause i have all fishes in the list except dog fish i dont know why maybe it hates me
how can i catch the seacrab?
Erm anyone got the paddlefish? i think it can only be caught using the cash bait!
I got…
(Just to add)
Mosquito fish – Onion
Sea Slug – Pear
Silver Arowana – Biscuit
Lemon Fish – Lemon
Paddlefish – Onion
Clam with Pearl – Onion
Clown Knifefish – Onion
Broken Mystery Box – Pear
Sheepfish – Onion (not only carrot !)
Red Salmon – Homegrown sweetheart root
Clown Fish – Onion
I use onion A LOT because it get`s A LOT of good fishes :>
i caught a black gohst knife fish with strawberry and watermelon xxx
Red Demekin Goldfish by Pink Donut
Blue Ram fish by Carrot.
I got a Black Ghost Knifefish by using a soft pretzel. . .
I want a melon fish!
Thx for the tips! I finally got a crab using a carrot that is bought from the food shop. It’s really hard to get a octopus…I tried many times using carrot that is bought from the food shop but it doesn’t seemed to be working.
i just got a clown knifefish with a leek.
lol a golden butterfly fish by leek too and blue ram with leek
bluegill with tamago sushi
and red salmon by ebi sushi
Strawberry fish by strawberry
i caught a clownfish with a bone .. you might want to add that (:
whatsa leeeek?!
homegrown halloween lolly = jack o lanternfish
i just caught an african butterfly fish with a hotdog, and i dont see that on list…
i caught a turkey fish using a whole pumpkin pie
i just caught an Amberstone bug with a pear